Supreme Court Petitions Raise Tax Questions for Prediction Markets

Supreme Court Petitions Raise Tax Questions for Prediction Markets Featured News Image

Summary

  • Robinhood, Kalshi and Crypto.com cases reach the Supreme Court over state gambling regulations
  • Robinhood warns federal wagering taxes could affect its rapidly growing event contracts business
  • NYU researchers argue sports prediction contracts likely qualify as taxable wagers under federal law

Three disputes involving Robinhood, Kalshi and Crypto.com have reached the U.S. Supreme Court, raising questions about state gambling regulation and its potential implications for federal wagering taxes.

The companies are involved in separate cases concerning whether sports event contracts traded on federally regulated exchanges are subject to state gambling laws. Responses in all three cases are due December 7, 2026.

Although the petitions do not directly ask the Supreme Court to determine federal tax liability, their outcome could influence how prediction markets are treated as operators face growing regulatory scrutiny.

Three Prediction Market Cases Reach the Supreme Court

Robinhood Derivatives petitioned the Supreme Court on September 10 after losing its challenge against Nevada gaming regulators in the Ninth Circuit.

Crypto.com’s derivatives exchange, North American Derivatives Exchange, filed a similar petition on September 11 after an unfavorable ruling in Nevada.

Both companies argue that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) exclusive authority over event contracts traded on federally regulated exchanges.

New Jersey took the opposite position in its September 2 petition, asking the Supreme Court to review an April ruling in Kalshi’s favor from the Third Circuit.

The state argues that federal commodities oversight does not prevent it from applying gambling regulations to sports prediction markets.

The conflicting appellate decisions have created uncertainty over whether operators can offer sports event contracts nationwide without obtaining individual state gambling licenses.

The Supreme Court has not agreed to hear any of the three cases. The December 7 deadlines concern responses to the petitions, not a decision on their merits.

The justices must first decide whether to accept the appeals before any substantive ruling can follow.

Robinhood Warns Federal Wagering Taxes Could Affect Its Business

While the Supreme Court petitions focus on regulatory jurisdiction, Robinhood has separately acknowledged uncertainty over the federal tax treatment of event contracts.

In its October 28 quarterly filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the company disclosed that Robinhood Derivatives had not collected or remitted federal wagering excise taxes on its event contracts.

Robinhood explained that it does not consider those contracts subject to the tax, while warning that unfavorable interpretations of federal or state tax laws could impose additional costs.

Sections 4401 and 4421 of the Internal Revenue Code establish federal wagering excise taxes and relevant definitions.

Section 4401 generally applies a 0.25% tax to authorized wagers and a higher rate to certain unauthorized wagers. Whether sports event contracts fall within those provisions remains disputed.

Prediction market operators distinguish their exchanges from conventional sportsbooks by emphasizing that participants trade contracts against one another rather than placing bets directly against a bookmaker.

That distinction is central to their regulatory arguments, but it does not automatically determine their treatment under federal tax law.

An unfavorable tax interpretation could create additional operating costs even if an exchange successfully establishes that federal commodities law overrides state gambling restrictions.

NYU Researchers Challenge the Tax Exemption Argument

Researchers at New York University’s Tax Law Center have argued that sports event contracts offered through prediction markets likely qualify as wagers under federal tax law.

In an October 5 analysis, they concluded that the applicable rules extend beyond the federal excise tax to include income tax treatment of winnings and restrictions on deducting gambling losses.

The researchers also challenged the idea that federal commodities regulation necessarily shields prediction markets from wagering taxes.

Their argument distinguishes two separate legal questions: whether states can regulate event contracts as gambling and whether the federal government can tax those contracts as wagers.

This distinction matters because a Supreme Court ruling favoring operators on federal preemption would not, by itself, establish an exemption from federal wagering taxes.

The NYU analysis is a legal interpretation, not a binding determination by a court or the Internal Revenue Service.

Growing Event Contract Revenue Raises the Financial Stakes

Robinhood’s latest financial results illustrate why the tax question matters to prediction market operators.

The company reported $173 million in event contract revenue for the third quarter of 2026, compared with $27 million during the same period in 2025.

That represents growth of approximately 541%, making event contracts an increasingly important contributor to Robinhood’s transaction-based revenue.

Robinhood also reported that customers traded 16.4 billion event contracts during the quarter.

The financial impact of a wagering tax would depend on how the relevant transactions are classified, which activities are taxable and how the applicable tax base is calculated.

A tax imposed on wagering amounts would operate differently from a tax on an exchange’s revenue, making the distinction particularly important for high-volume trading platforms.

Vladimir Ilic Author Avatar
Author: Vladimir Ilic
Updated:

Vladimir is a senior iGaming writer and editor, adept at breaking down the key details of crypto casinos and sportsbooks so players don’t have to, delivering honest, player-focused information that actually matters.